Can One Infraction Justify Dismissal When the Loss Is Substantial Enough? | G.R. No. 219664
Raysag and Entrina, Inventory Specialists entrusted with the high-end cosmetics stockroom of Rustan’s Makati, were dismissed after an audit revealed that merchandise worth over half a million pesos had gone missing under their watch. They argued they were illegally dismissed, pointing out that even the NLRC’s own finding of gross and habitual neglect required a pattern of repeated infractions, not just a single incident. The Supreme Court ruled that while an isolated act of negligence is generally not enough to justify dismissal, this rule is not absolute — given the substantial value of the loss and the position of trust and confidence held by the employees, dismissal was justified even assuming it was their first offense. However, the Court also found that the company failed to observe procedural due process, since its first notice never warned the employees that dismissal was a possible consequence of the charges against them.









