Sadsad Tamesis Legal and Accountancy Firm

Case Digest

Can One Infraction Justify Dismissal When the Loss Is Substantial Enough? | G.R. No. 219664

Raysag and Entrina, Inventory Specialists entrusted with the high-end cosmetics stockroom of Rustan’s Makati, were dismissed after an audit revealed that merchandise worth over half a million pesos had gone missing under their watch. They argued they were illegally dismissed, pointing out that even the NLRC’s own finding of gross and habitual neglect required a pattern of repeated infractions, not just a single incident. The Supreme Court ruled that while an isolated act of negligence is generally not enough to justify dismissal, this rule is not absolute — given the substantial value of the loss and the position of trust and confidence held by the employees, dismissal was justified even assuming it was their first offense. However, the Court also found that the company failed to observe procedural due process, since its first notice never warned the employees that dismissal was a possible consequence of the charges against them.

Can One Infraction Justify Dismissal When the Loss Is Substantial Enough? | G.R. No. 219664 Read More »

Can a Party to a Void Marriage Donate Common Property Without the Other’s Consent? | G.R. No. 233365

Eliodoro and Adelita lived together as husband and wife, but their marriage was later declared void ab initio. While Adelita was still alive, Eliodoro donated their common property to his grandson Nicxon without her consent. After Eliodoro’s death, his daughter Avegail sought to annul the donation, arguing it was prejudicial to her inheritance. Nicxon countered that under the Civil Code’s rules on co-ownership, Eliodoro could validly dispose of his own share even without Adelita’s consent. The Supreme Court ruled that Article 147 of the Family Code, which governs property relations in a void marriage or cohabitation, expressly prohibits a party from disposing of his or her share in common property without the other’s consent until the cohabitation ends — and this special rule prevails over the general rules on co-ownership under Article 493 of the Civil Code. The donation was declared void in its entirety.

Can a Party to a Void Marriage Donate Common Property Without the Other’s Consent? | G.R. No. 233365 Read More »

Silence on a Defective Information Means Waiver | G.R. No. 235991

In this case, Lira was charged with two counts of Murder for the shooting deaths of Carlos and Elisa Dulfo, allegedly connected to a barangay election loss. The RTC convicted him, but the CA downgraded the crime to Homicide because the Informations did not specify the acts constituting treachery and abuse of superior strength. The Supreme Court reinstated the Murder conviction, ruling that Lira waived any defect in the Informations by failing to file a motion to quash or a motion for bill of particulars and by entering his plea and going to trial.

Silence on a Defective Information Means Waiver | G.R. No. 235991 Read More »

Impossible Crime Fails Without Proof That the Victim Was Already Dead | G.R. No. 228945

In G.R. No. 228945, Hesson was convicted of murder for stabbing and mutilating Fernando Adlawan after Junello had struck and hacked him. Hesson argued he should only be liable for an impossible crime because Fernando was already dead. The Supreme Court rejected this, since the lone witness merely assumed Fernando was dead from seeing him lie motionless, without checking his pulse, heartbeat, or breathing. Even if Fernando was already dead, Hesson would still be liable for murder because of the conspiracy between him and Junello.

Impossible Crime Fails Without Proof That the Victim Was Already Dead | G.R. No. 228945 Read More »

Unnotarized Service Agreement Fails to Defeat Employee Status  | G.R. No. 243414

In G.R. No. 243414, GDI Lighting Solutions hired Jasmin Unating in 2012 as a Market Assistant, later promoting her to Manager/Supervisor, and claimed she was merely an independent contractor under a Manpower Service Agreement. The Supreme Court found she was an employee: the agreement was undated, unnotarized, and unwitnessed, while she presented a company ID and emails showing work directly related to the company’s main business, and GDI Lighting offered no proof of substantial capital as a legitimate contractor. Where the evidence is in equipoise, doubts are resolved in favor of labor.

Unnotarized Service Agreement Fails to Defeat Employee Status  | G.R. No. 243414 Read More »

No Proven Notice of Dishonor, No BP 22 Presumption | G.R. No. 277047

In G.R. No. 277047, the Supreme Court dealt with Spouses Carlos, who bought tires from Tire Star, Inc. on installment and paid with six post-dated checks that were all dishonored for “Account Closed.” Under BP 22, knowledge of insufficient funds is presumed only if the drawer fails to pay within five banking days after receiving notice of dishonor, so service of that notice is essential. Tire Star’s messenger testified that the notice was personally served at the spouses’ store and accepted by their employee, and the spouses offered only a bare denial, which the Court found insufficient. The Court upheld the conviction and the legal interest running from extrajudicial demand. It also standardized the rules going forward: notice of dishonor may be served personally, by registered mail, or electronically, and the service must be proven by an affidavit narrating its circumstances, with supporting documentation.

No Proven Notice of Dishonor, No BP 22 Presumption | G.R. No. 277047 Read More »

Does an employee’s voluntary resignation defeat a subsequent complaint for illegal dismissal? | G.R. No. 202724

The Court ruled that Lobetania, Dimaiwat, Velasco, and Aguirre’s voluntary resignations barred their illegal dismissal claims, and in any case all petitioners—including Bance, who did not resign—were validly dismissed for just cause (breach of trust and fraud involving missing funds and an abused tuition-discount scheme). Still, because the University skipped the required two-notice procedure, Bance was awarded P30,000 in nominal damages despite the dismissal itself being upheld as valid.

Does an employee’s voluntary resignation defeat a subsequent complaint for illegal dismissal? | G.R. No. 202724 Read More »

Does one mortgage securing two separate debts bar suing on one after foreclosing the other?  | G.R. No. 203194

In G.R. No. 203194, the Supreme Court ruled that a mortgage covering two separate obligations doesn’t merge them into one cause of action—since a mortgage is merely accessory to the principal loans it secures, foreclosing on one debt doesn’t bar a separate collection suit on a distinct, independent debt, even if both are secured by the same mortgage and due at the same time.

Does one mortgage securing two separate debts bar suing on one after foreclosing the other?  | G.R. No. 203194 Read More »

Can an unwritten or verbal sale of land still be considered valid? | G.R. No. 256343

In this case, the heirs of a registered landowner sought to recover possession of a property occupied by their relatives, who claimed they had purchased the land decades earlier through an oral agreement with the deceased owner. Although no written deed of sale existed, the buyers had long possessed and cultivated the property and presented tax declarations and receipts showing payment of taxes over the years. The Supreme Court ruled that while the Civil Code requires sales of real property to be in writing for enforceability, an oral sale that has already been partially or fully executed may still be considered valid and binding. The Court emphasized that delivery of the property and continued possession are strong indicators that the sale had been consummated.

Can an unwritten or verbal sale of land still be considered valid? | G.R. No. 256343 Read More »

Can a judge be sanctioned for using harsh and offensive language in court premises? | A.M. No. 23-04-15-SC

In this case, a Regional Trial Court judge confronted a PAO lawyer who briefly parked near a PWD access ramp inside the Justice Hall of Marikina. Although the lawyer repeatedly apologized, the judge publicly berated him using harsh and demeaning language, later proceeding to the PAO office to continue his tirade in front of witnesses. While the Supreme Court recognized that the judge’s concern for maintaining order and accessibility within court premises was legitimate, it held that his manner of enforcement was improper and disproportionate. The Court ultimately admonished the judge, reminding members of the judiciary that they must always exercise courtesy, restraint, and conduct consistent with the dignity of judicial office.

Can a judge be sanctioned for using harsh and offensive language in court premises? | A.M. No. 23-04-15-SC Read More »

Scroll to Top