Sadsad Tamesis Legal and Accountancy Firm

Silence on a Defective Information Means Waiver | G.R. No. 235991

Silence on a Defective Information Means Waiver | G.R. No. 235991 | PHOTO: Pavel Danilyuk / Pexels

Facts

Accused-appellant seeks to appeal the CA decision finding him guilty beyond reasonable doubt, but downgrading the crime from Murder to Homicide. Lira and his companions were indicted for two counts of Murder as defined and penalized under Article 248 of the RPC.

The witness for the prosecution presented that in the afternoon of December 31, 2010 in Northern Samar, Dagsa saw the two victims lying on the ground who were later on identified as Carlos Dulfo and his wife Elisa. Dagsa looked for Rhea, the daughter of the victims to inform her of what he saw along the highway. Based from the postmortem examinations, Elisa died from a single gunshot wound, while Carlos expired due to multiple gunshot wounds. The prosecution claims that the possible reason why Carlos and Elisa were killed, another witness, Arnel attributed it to politics because Carlos defeated Lira in the barangay elections. The defense denied the allgations, claiming that accused was in his house the whole day of December 31.

The RTC convicted Lira of the crimes charged, to which the CA modified on appeal by downgrading the offense from Murder to Homicide, holding that the Informations did not give the particular acts constituting the circumstances of treachery and abuse of superior strength.

ISSUE: Whether the CA’s modification of downgrading the offense from Murder to Homicide is proper.

Ruling

NO. The accused failed to question the sufficiency of the Information by availing the remedies provided under procedural rules, therefore he is deemed to have waived any of the defects in the Information filed against him.

The CA adhered to the ruling in the case of People v. Valdez where it was settled that to discharge its burden of informing the accused of the charge, the State must specify in the information the details of the crime and any circumstance that aggravates his liability for the crime. Meanwhile, there is a separate line of cases in which an allegation in the Information that the killing was attended “with treachery” is already sufficient to inform the accused that he was being charged with Murder instead of simply Homicide.

The Court thus convicts Lira of Murder instead of Homicide. The Court maintains that the right to question the defects in an Information is not absolute. In fact, defects in an Information with regard to its form may be waived by the accused. In the instant case, Lira has waived his right to question the defects in the Informations filed against him. In People v. Palarca, the Court held that the accused therein may still be validly convicted of the crime despite the insufficiency of the Information. Likewise, in People v. Solar, citing People v. Razonable, the Court held that if an Information is defective, such that it fails to sufficiently inform the accused of the nature and cause of the accusation against him, then it is the accused’s duty to enforce his right through the procedural rules created by the Court for its proper enforcement.

In the present case, Lira did not question the supposed insufficiency of the Information filed against him through either a motion to quash or motion for bill of particulars. He voluntarily entered his plea during the arraignment and proceeded with the trial. Thus, he is deemed to have waived any of the waivable defects in the Informations, including the supposed lack of particularity in the description of the attendant circumstances. In other words, Lira is deemed to have understood the acts imputed against him by the Information. The CA therefore erred in modifying Lira’s conviction in the way that it did when he had effectively waived the right to question his conviction on that ground.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top