Sadsad Tamesis Legal and Accountancy Firm

Can One Infraction Justify Dismissal When the Loss Is Substantial Enough? | G.R. No. 219664

Can One Infraction Justify Dismissal When the Loss Is Substantial Enough? | G.R. No. 219664 | PHOTO: Mikhail Nilov / Pexels

Facts

Respondents Raysag and Entrina started working for petitioner in November 1974 and March 1994. Subsequently, they were assigned as Inventory Specialists at the Cosmetics, Perfumeries & Toiletries (CP & T) stockroom in Rustan’s Department Store, Makati City (Rustan’s Makati), on October 16, 2006, and July 1, 2005, respectively.

On July 19, 2022, Azucena Baliwas, a Beauty Consultant for La Prairie, a high-end skin care merchandise in Rustan’s Makati, discovered that a La Prairie Cellular Resurfacing Cream was missing from the CP & T stockroom. She informed Edna Leonardo, La Prairie’s Counter Manager at Rustan’s Makati, of her discovery. Leonardo then made a physical count of all La Prairie merchandise in the selling area and in the CP & T stockroom with the assistance of Baliwas. However, the missing item could not be found. Leonardo further discovered that 62 La Prairie skin care merchandise amounting P617,775.00 were actually missing from the CP & T stockroom, prompting her to request for a thorough inventory by the petitioner’s Inventory Control Group (ICG). The ICG performed a count of La Prairie’s stocks inventory at Rustan’s Makati and found an unaccounted variance totaling P537,554.00. The ICG endorsed its findings to the petitioner’s Internal Audit Division (IAD).

The IAD made its own inventory on August 11, 2011 of all stocks vis-à-vis the reported inventory discrepancies as endorsed by the ICG. On October 4, 2011, the IAD issued an Audit Report, with an attached list of unaccounted or missing items, finding that there were 54 missing La Prairie merchandise from Rustan’s Makati CP & T stockroom amounting to P510,800.00. Thus, the IAD urged further investigation by petitioner’s Legal Department.

On October 11, 2011, petitioner sent Notices to Explain to respondents in reference to the report provided by the ICG that there was an accounted variance of P537,554.00 in the La Prairie inventory covering the period of January 2011 to October 10, 2011. Accordingly, the respondents were required “to explain why they should not be held accountable for the losses of petitioner due to the aforementioned shortage at La Prairie and why no appropriate action should be taken against them.” 

On December 29, 2011, respondents were subjected to a voluntary polygraph test examination conducted by Truth Verifier Systems, Inc., in which the lie detector examiner found respondents’ responses as “deceptive” anent the questions on any involvement in the pilferage and losses of any of the La Prairie merchandise inside the Rustan’s Makati CP & T stockroom.

On January 10, 2012, petitioner served Notices of Preventive Suspension to respondents in connection with the investigation of their involvement in the merchandise losses of La Prairie, MAC and other CP & T brands. In separate letters dated February 1, 2012, petitioner informed respondents that their employment would be terminated effective February 1, 2012 due to the offense they committed which led to the losses from the CP & T stockroom of merchandise under La Prairie brand amounting to P509,004.00.

On March 20, 2012, Raysag filed before the NLRC NCR Arbitration Branch a complaint against petitioner and its officers for or illegal dismissal, non-payment of Emergency Cost of Living Allowance (ECOLA), vacation leave and sick leave pay, 13th month pay, separation pay, retirement benefits and claims for moral and exemplary damages, and attorney’s fees. Entrina followed suit on March 22, 2012 by filing a complaint for the same causes of action except for separation pay and retirement benefits.

The LA rendered a Decision, finding the dismissal of respondents illegal, and ruled that the Notice to Explain dated October 11, 2011 did not conform with the first written notice requirement in dismissing an employee, considering that the particular acts or omissions allegedly committed by respondents and the particular items/products and their corresponding prices or itemized monetary value being referred to as the accounted variances were not indicated therein.

Upon appeal, the NLRC reversed the LA decision, ruling that respondents’ employment were justly terminated on the ground of gross and habitual neglect. The NLRC emphasized that the subject skin care merchandise went missing from Rustan’s Makati CP & T stockroom between January and October 2011 during the watch of respondents who were Inventory Specialists to whom rested the responsibility of ensuring strict and faithful compliance with petitioner’s policies and procedures on safeguarding all the stocks in the stockroom and keeping proper inventory of the same. Aggrieved, respondents filed a petition for certiorari before the CA.

The CA found grave abuse of discretion on the part of the NLRC in declaring that petitioner had proven, through substantial evidence, that the termination of respondents’ employment complied with the requirements of substantial and procedural due process. Contrary to the finding of the NLRC, the CA held that petitioner failed to prove respondents’ gross neglect of duty in the performance of their functions

ISSUES:

(1) Whether the CA erred in ruling that respondents were illegally dismissed for lack of substantial evidence that they were guilty of gross and habitual neglect of duty; (2) Whether the CA erred in ruling that respondents were illegally dismissed for lack of procedural due process; (3) Whether the CA erred in ruling that respondents are entitled to separation pay, retirement pay, and other monetary award.

Ruling

(1) YES. In this case, the Court finds, under the circumstances pertaining herein, that it was just and reasonable for petitioner to dismiss respondents even, assuming, that it was the first time that they committed the infraction. The Court takes into account two important factors. First is the quantity and the substantial amount or value of the merchandise lost, amounting to P509,044.00. Second, respondents’ position is necessarily one of trust and confidence. Petitioner cannot legally be compelled to continue with the employment of respondents who are entrusted with the care, custody, and safekeeping of high-end cosmetic products, but who just committed gross negligence which resulted to missing assigned products amounting to an enormous amount of around half a million pesos. Clearly, respondents’ continued tenure is patently inimical to the petitioner’s business interest.

(2) NO. The first notice must Inform outright the employee that an investigation will be conducted on the charges specified in such notice which, if proven, will result in the employee’s dismissal. Otherwise, the employee may just disregard the notice as a warning without any disastrous consequence to be anticipated. Absent such statement, the first notice falls short of the requirement of due process. In this case, the Notice to Explain96 dated October 11, 2011 sent by petitioner to respondents.

It is apparent on the face of the Notice that there is no indication that respondents could be terminated from employment. No such intention to dismiss respondents can be inferred from the general tenor of the Notice. Neither did the Notice apprise respondents of the specific causes or grounds for their possible termination, or the company rules or policies they violated. Respondents were only notified that their termination was due to gross neglect of duty in the Notice of Termination dated February 1, 2012. The Notices of Preventive Suspension98 dated January 10, 2012 did not rectify petitioner’s violation of the first written notice requirement. As admitted by petitioner, it refers to the subsequent string of additional losses after the actual investigation was conducted in relation to the October 11, 2011 Notice to Explain and the corresponding Investigation Report dated December 19, 2011.

(3) YES. Finding that there is just cause in the dismissal of respondents, but without the proper observance of procedural due process on the part of petitioner, the dismissal, as mentioned at the outset, remains valid. Accordingly, the respondents are not entitled to backwages, reinstatement or separation pay in lieu thereof, retirement benefits with regard to Raysag, and attorney’s fees. Under Article 279 of the Labor Code, only unjustly dismissed employees are entitled to reinstatement and backwages. Likewise, retirement benefits cannot be granted to an employee dismissed for just cause.

Although long years of service might generally be considered for the award of separation benefits or some form of financial assistance to mitigate the effects of termination, this case is not the appropriate instance for generosity. xxx However, petitioner shall be held liable for nominal damages for failure to faithfully and strictly comply with the due process requirements in terminating the employment of respondents.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top