Sadsad Tamesis Legal and Accountancy Firm

Impossible Crime Fails Without Proof That the Victim Was Already Dead | G.R. No. 228945

Impossible Crime Fails Without Proof That the Victim Was Already Dead | G.R. No. 228945 | PHOTO: cottonbro studio / Pexels

Facts

The prosecution presented its lone witness, Sario Joaquin (Sario), who testified that on July 15, 2006, he was at the flea market of Guincalaban, Tayasan, Negros Oriental together with his friends Hesson, Junello and one Remmy Casello (Remmy). While in the market, Hesson and Junello discussed a plan to kill the victim, Fernando Adlawan (Fernando) as ordered by one Enrile Yosores (Enrile). 

Hesson, Junello, Remmy and Sario left the flea market and went to the house of Fernando. Junello, upon seeing Fernando, asked for a cigarette lighter. After Fernando gave Junello the lighter, the latter struck Fernando on the nape with a piece of firewood. Junello then took a bolo and hacked Fernando’s body on the side. Fernando lost consciousness and as he laid motionless on the ground, Hesson stabbed him twice in the chest using a knife. Hesson then sliced open Fernando’s chest and took out the latter’s heart using the same knife. Junello followed and took out Fernando’s liver using a bolo.

Sario was on the opposite side watching the incident. He and Remmy did not attempt to stop the two (2) accused or run away for fear that the latter would kill them. Sario went home from the crime scene and did not tell anyone about the incident because Hesson and Junello threatened to kill him if he did so.

After the incident, Remmy was killed by Enrile during the town fiesta of Guincalaban.

The testimony of Florencio Adlawan, Fernando’s father, was dispensed with after the defense admitted the accused’s civil liability and the funeral expenses incurred by the family. Likewise, the testimony of Dr. Myrasol Zuniega, who examined the victim’s body, was not presented because the defense admitted the existence of the death certificate indicating that the immediate cause of death is internal hemorrhage and the underlying cause is multiple stab wounds.

The trial court found Hesson guilty beyond reasonable doubt of the crime of Murder qualified by treachery. The CA affirmed the trial court’s conviction with modification only as to the damages awarded.

ISSUE: Whether or not the crime committed was not murder but an impossible crime

Ruling

NO. Without admitting his guilt, Hesson argues that he should only be convicted of committing an impossible crime. Allegedly, he cannot be held liable for Murder because it was legally impossible for him to kill Fernando as the latter was already dead when Hesson stabbed him.

However, the Court is not convinced. The requisites of an impossible crime are: (1) that the act performed would be an offense against persons or property; (2) that the act was done with evil intent; and (3) that its accomplishment was inherently impossible, or the means employed was either inadequate or ineffectual.

The third element, inherent impossibility of accomplishing the crime, was explained more clearly by the Court in the case of Intod v. Court of Appeals:

Legal impossibility occurs where the intended acts, even if completed, would not amount to a crime. xxx

x x x x

The impossibility of killing a person already dead falls in this category.

The victim’s fact of death before he was stabbed by Hesson was not sufficiently established by the defense. While Sario testified that he thought Fernando was already dead after he was hacked by Junello because the former was already lying on the ground motionless, this statement cannot sufficiently support the conclusion that, indeed, Fernando was already dead when Hesson stabbed him. Sario’s opinion of Femando’s death was arrived at by merely looking at the latter’s body. No other act was done to ascertain this, such as checking of Fernando’s pulse, heartbeat or breathing.

Likewise, considering that Sario was in the middle of a surely stressful and frightful event, he cannot be expected to have focused enough and be fit to determine if Fernando was indeed dead when Sario thought he was. More importantly, even assuming that it was Junello who killed Fernando and that the latter was already dead when he was stabbed by Hesson, Hesson is still liable for murder because of the clear presence of conspiracy between Hesson and Junello. As such, Junello’s acts are likewise, legally, Hesson’s acts.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top